@KydThe16th: Nah. Maybe it wasn't the biggest financial success of all time, but it's generally well-regarded. It has fairly high ratings both from game journalists and gamers and a lot of gaming youtubers adoring it. Also it's a TPS.
For underrated I'd think of something like the original Prey or Wolfenstein (2008), though those weren't low rated, but Wolfenstein does have a mixed reputation amog gamers. Also you can't buy any of those unless you hunt down a physical copy.
Or maybe Legendary, which does have mixed ratings and while not exactly a hidden gem, it's a decent shooter with some interesting/unique aspects regarding its setting.
For underrated I'd think of something like the original Prey or Wolfenstein (2008), though those weren't low rated, but Wolfenstein does have a mixed reputation amog gamers. Also you can't buy any of those unless you hunt down a physical copy.
Or maybe Legendary, which does have mixed ratings and while not exactly a hidden gem, it's a decent shooter with some interesting/unique aspects regarding its setting.